Dr Michael Plant conducted an in-person site visit to better understand the StrongMinds programme and the people in it. We don’t expect site visits can, or should, be decisive for evaluation purposes (they are ‘anecdata’), but they can nevertheless be informative.
Visitor: Dr Michael Plant, Founder & Research Director at the Happier Lives Institute
Date of visit: 11 April 2024
Document written: 19 April 2024
Dr Michael Plant conducted an in-person site visit to better understand the Friendship Bench programme and the people in it. We don’t expect site visits can, or should, be decisive for evaluation purposes (they are ‘anecdata’), but they can nevertheless be informative.
Visitor: Dr Michael Plant, Founder & Research Director at the Happier Lives Institute
Date of visit: 04 April 2024
Document written: 10 April 2024
28 November 2023 | Anti-malarial Nets, Cash Transfers, Deworming, Giving, Global Priorities, Interventions, Mental Health, Pain, Psychotherapy, Reducing Lead Exposure, Research, Happier Lives Institute, Donors, Policymakers, Researchers In this report, we provide an overview of all our evaluations to date as well as our conclusions for Giving Season 2023.
27 November 2023 | Global Priorities, Interventions, Mental Health, Psychotherapy, Joel McGuire, Maxwell Klapow, Michael Plant, Ryan Dwyer, Samuel Dupret, Donors, Policymakers, Researchers In this substantial update to our work on psychotherapy we conduct a systematic review, a meta-analysis, and cost-effectiveness analyses of two charities who deliver psychotherapy (StrongMinds and Friendship Bench). This is a working report that will be updated over time, results may change.
9 June 2023 | Deworming, Global Priorities, Measurement, Moral Uncertainty, Philosophy, Psychology, Psychotherapy, Theoretical Research, Michael Plant, Donors, Policymakers, Researchers On the 2nd of June 2023, Elie Hassenfeld was interviewed on the 80'000 hours podcast. Here, we present our responses.
On the 22nd of March 2023, GiveWell posted an “Assessment of Happier Lives Institute’s Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of StrongMinds”. Here, we present our responses. First, a general response from Michael. Second, a technical response from Joel.
18 November 2022 | Anti-malarial Nets, Cash Transfers, Interventions, Moral Uncertainty, Philosophy, Psychotherapy, Theoretical Research, Joel McGuire, Michael Plant, Samuel Dupret, Donors, Policymakers, Researchers How should we compare the value of extending lives to improving lives? Doing so requires us to make various philosophical assumptions, either implicitly or explicitly. But these choices are rarely acknowledged or discussed by decision-makers, all of them are controversial, and they have significant implications for how resources should be distributed.
We update our previous analysis to incorporate the household spillover effects for cash transfers and psychotherapy. We estimate that psychotherapy is 9 times (95% CI: 2, 100) more cost-effective than cash transfers. The charity StrongMinds is estimated to be 9 times (95% CI: 1, 90) more cost-effective than the charity GiveDirectly.
Drawing on evidence from over 80 studies and over 140,000 participants, we compare the cost-effectiveness of cash transfers and psychotherapy by estimating their effect on the recipient's subjective wellbeing and affective mental health.
This report explains how we determined the cost-effectiveness of StrongMinds using subjective wellbeing and affective mental health.
This report explains how we determined the cost-effectiveness of group or task-shifted psychotherapy in low- and middle-income countries using subjective wellbeing and affective mental health.
The Mental Health Programme Evaluation Project (MHPEP) was an HLI-led volunteer project that ran from February 2019 to October 2021.The principal aim of the project was to identify and direct donations to highly impactful mental health programmes.
This report investigates the global burden of mental illness. It sets out how big the problem is, how much spending it receives, and how those resources are allocated. It then focuses specifically on what can be done to reduce anxiety and depression in low-income countries.
